Development News for Syracuse, New York

Parkville Hotel Facade Alterations Under Review; Window Material and Sill Details Debated

The Board reviewed a minor site plan modification for facade alterations at 713-715 East Genesee Street (Parkville Hotel), specifically focusing on window replacements and signage. The proposed windows are a fiberglass/PVC composite system, designed to simulate a double-hung appearance with a horizontal mutton. These windows will be set back from the brick finish to allow for sealing. Concerns were raised by the board regarding the material (PVC vs. fiberglass) and its longevity compared to original wood windows, as well as the potential for condensation and the loss of historic window sills on the rear facade. The applicant proposed an aluminum pan detail for the sills. Signage changes include removing existing 'Park View' signs and adding new Hampton Inn signage on the front canopy and rear facade. The board generally supported the project, with specific comments and recommendations regarding window materials and sill treatment, suggesting a compromise on the sill detail.

Mosque Expansion Denied Due to Scale and Historic Character Concerns

The Board denied an application for expansion of the Islamic Society of Central New York (ISCNY) mosque at 925 Comstock Avenue. The denial was based on the project's non-compliance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, specifically concerning the scale and massing of the proposed addition in relation to the historic neighborhood character. The applicant was encouraged to resubmit with a new design that better aligns with these standards. The denial was without prejudice, allowing the applicant to reapply. A motion to deny was made, seconded, and passed with specific reference to Standards #2 and #9.